Istigatha 3: Qur'an Says the Dead Cannot Hear? Recommended Watch

eSHIA - Sh. Dr. Agha Mohammadi The Salafis and those who are influenced by their ideology or those who are confused claim that Istigatha to Prophet Muhammad (s) or the Aimmah ('a) is shirk and you cannot call on them because they are dead and there are verses of the Holy Qur'an that say the dead and those in their graves cannot hear. In this, part 3, we will give proof from the Holy Qur'an that the dead can hear and we will refute the verses they misinterpret. WATCH OUR ISTIGATHA SERIES WHICH ACADEMICALLY ANALYZES THIS TOPIC YOU WILL NEVER BE CONFUSED ABOUT ISTIGATHA BEING SHIRK EVER AGAIN. PLEASE SHARE WIDELY SO OTHERS CAN BENEFIT ALSO MAY ALLAH REWARD YOU FOR YOUR HELP IN GUIDING OTHERS. THANK YOU. Istigatha is a Qu'ranic concept based on tawhid. Please watch Istigatha 1 on our channel for proof. Calling on other than Allah is not shirk. Please watch Istigatha 2 on our channel for proof from the Holy Qur'an. CHAPTERS: 00:00 The Salafi Claim 01:01 Shi'a Rebuttal - They are like Kuffar (Qur'an) 02:59 The dead do hear (Qur'an) 03:37 The Prophet hears (Qur'an) 05:23 Intro to Video eSHIA 05:34 Ulema's Rebuttal 06:53 Ibn Taymiya says we do Ta'wil (4:64) 09:13 You can't make dead hear (Q 30:52) 09: 32 You can't make those in graves hear (Q 35:19 - 23) 11:10 Mufassirin View - Shi'a Sunni 15:23 The faithless vs. the dead (Q 27:67 27:80) 16:05 The faithful (8:20) 16:31 Talking to dead (7:91-93) 17:03 Talking to dead (7:78-79) 17:57 Conclusion 18:08 An Insane thing to say 18:41 Outro Sheikh Morteza agha Mohammadi has a PhD in Islamic studies from hawza 'ilmiyya of Qom. He also holds a second PhD in Shia Studies from the University of Religions and Denominations in Qom. He is a vice chancellor, professor and has authored many books and articles in English and Farsi - to see his writings go to his telegram channel: ... or visit his youtube channel, where he has covered Istegatha and Wasilah in detail: Tawassul an